What is the Difference Between a YubiKey and a Passkey?

What is the Difference Between a YubiKey and a Passkey?#

The difference between a YubiKey and a passkey lies in how they manage and store authentication credentials. YubiKeys store credentials directly on the device, making them non-replicable and tied to the physical hardware.

Discuss passkeys news and questions in r/passkey.

Join Subreddit

In contrast, passkeys are platform-generated and are mostly synced across devices using cloud accounts, offering greater convenience but relying on cloud-based security measures.

The key difference: YubiKeys are hardware-based, while passkeys can be cloud-synced.
YubiKeys provide a higher level of physical security by storing credentials on the device.
Passkeys offer convenience by syncing across multiple devices, making them more user-friendly.

In-Depth Overview#

YubiKeys and passkeys both play crucial roles in modern authentication methods, but they cater to different security and convenience needs.

YubiKey Overview#

YubiKeys are hardware security keys that provide robust protection by storing FIDO2-enabled credentials directly on the device. This means:

Non-Replicable Credentials: Credentials are tied to the physical hardware, meaning they cannot be copied or transferred to another device.
Physical Security: YubiKeys require physical possession of the key to authenticate, which significantly reduces the risk of remote attacks.

Passkey Overview#

Passkeys, on the other hand, are digital credentials generated and managed by the operating system or platform, such as iOS, Android, or Windows. Key features include:

Cloud Syncing: Passkeys are automatically synced across devices using the user's cloud account or a third-party password manager, which allows seamless access from multiple devices.
Convenience: This synchronization makes it easier for users to access their accounts from different devices without the need for a physical key.

Become part of our Passkeys Community for updates & support.

Join

Choosing Between YubiKey and Passkey#

When deciding whether to use a YubiKey or a passkey, consider the following:

Security Needs: If your priority is maximum security, a YubiKey may be the better choice due to its hardware-based protection.
Convenience vs. Security Trade-Off: For users or companies looking for convenience and ease of access across multiple devices, passkeys offer a simpler, more user-friendly option.
Use Case Scenarios: YubiKeys are often preferred in enterprise environments or by individuals with high security needs, while passkeys are gaining traction in consumer applications due to their ease of use.